Trade liberalization, financial flexibility, and corporate tax avoidance tao chen and chen lin february, 2018 abstract we use import tariff reductions as a natural experiment to explore how trade liberalization causally affects the tax avoidance activities of u. Starbucks uk delivered its third straight year of profit in 2016 and paid. This paper first presents theoretical models that integrate avoidance and. Sep 18, 2018 starbucks european business paid an effective uk tax rate of just 2. Starbucks became a target for protesters because its uk stores were quite visible and reported billions of pounds of sales, while the company had paid almost no uk income taxes since beginning operations in 1998. Starbucks corporation starbucks, we or the company, an entity listed on nasdaq as sbux, is the ultimate parent of the companies that. Starbucks has been telling investors the business was profitable, even as it consistently reported losses. Standard models of taxation and their conclusions must reflect these realities. Starbucks accused of tax avoidance foodservice footprint. But the company has been using entirely legal tax avoidance schemes to report no profits and so escape paying uk tax.
Starbucks strategy in relation to taxation starbucks coffee company. Starbucks media coverage of starbucks not paying corporation tax in the united kingdom in the last four years has shocked and angered many members of the british public. Tax avoidance is not just a problem originating in the corporation. Its nearest competitors are paying multimillion pound tax bills to the treasury. The british want to stop starbucks from dodging taxes. Starbucks emea, which collects royalty income from 38 countries from norway to morocco, said it paid an effective tax rate of 23. Trade liberalization, financial flexibility, and corporate. Starbucks knew well in advance that one day this issue might come out in press and they had to be more prepared when responding to. Tax avoidance and evasion are pervasive in all countries, and tax structures are undoubtedly skewed by this reality. Ethics of tax avoidance by starbucks uk essay 277 words. Tax havens are jurisdictions which facilitate reduced taxes while forms of tax avoidance which use tax laws in ways. This animation explains how starbucks avoids paying uk taxes. Uk uncut, the group responsible for organizing many of the tax avoidance protests at starbucks stores in the uk, posted a press.
Tax avoidance controversies in the united kingdom a. Starbucks tax avoidance has brits frothing mad angry over the negligible corporate taxes that starbucks and other corporations have paid to britain despite huge revenues, a protest group is. Starbucks said that it had followed dutch and international tax rules, and that it disagreed with ms. Starbucks was accused of tax avoidance in 2012 after it emerged the chain had paid just. Social responsibility and tax avoidance sciencedirect. In one gambit described by law professor edward kleinbard, starbucks formed a company in switzerland called starbucks trading. Dec 07, 2012 starbucks tax avoidance has brits frothing mad angry over the negligible corporate taxes that starbucks and other corporations have paid to britain despite huge revenues, a protest group is. Since starbucks moved its europe, middle east and africa headquarters to london in october 2014, profits from licensees running starbucks across 38 countries, reaching from norway to morocco, portugal to russia, are now earned in the uk. While starbucks was very prominent in its social commitments to fair labor practices for workers and producers, the company extensively used tax avoidance strategies to pay corporate income taxes. Mcdonalds, by comparison, had a tax bill of over 80 million pounds on 3. In early december it was announced that starbucks paid just. Unitary tax provides a feasible solution to the corporation tax avoidance by. A tax is a financial charge or other levy imposed upon a tax payer by a state to fund various public expenditure.
How did starbucks manage with paying zero uk corporation tax. The fourmonth investigation by news agency reuters also found the firm had paid nothing in the. Starbucks said on april 16 it was relocating its european headquarters from the netherlands to britain a year after the u. Ending the free ride 4 uk list of figures 1 corporation tax avoidance 1. Sarrah kaviwala c40 shivani patil c33 vedant sharma c17 himani singh c27 devesh pandey c46 disha mahawar d20 2. Our tax and finance team manages the starbucks group tax matters on a daytoday basis. Tax avoidance is the legal usage of the tax regime in a single territory to ones own advantage to reduce the amount of tax that is payable by means that are within the law. Starbucks accused of tax avoidance the coffee chain starbucks has reportedly paid just. Despite starbucks arguing that its transfer pricing practices were in full compliance with regulatory requirements, public pressure for higher corporate tax payments led starbucks to increase its uk tax payment on transfer pricing income beyond regulatory. Starbucks funnelled tens of millions of dollars in royalty payments from amsterdam to an obscure british shell company. This apparent contradiction arises from tax avoidance, and sheds light on perfectly legal tactics used by multinationals the world over.
Two thirds of crossborder trade already takes place within corporations and more than half of world trade flows go through tax havens. Starbucks tries to draw a line under tax controversy. Tax sheltering is very similar, although unlike tax avoidance tax sheltering is not necessarily legal. Starbucks secret sauce for tax avoidance gives us an excellent example of how to create phony expenses out of nothing by mere transfers on paper between a parent company and a subsidiary. Ethics of tax avoidance by starbucks uk essays antiessays. Tax avoidance controversies in the united kingdom a, in sage business cases, sage publications ltd. Dec 15, 2015 starbucks became the poster child for corporate tax avoidance in 2012 after details of its meagre tax contribution emerged. Tax avoidance, tax evasion and tax havens may 2015. Starbucks european business paid an effective uk tax rate of just 2. While the tax avoidance practices starbucks used were common among. Jan 31, 2017 starbucks is effective in its corporate social responsibility efforts, although more effort is needed with regard to the stakeholder group of coffee farmers, as well as the issues of youth rates and tax avoidance in some regions. All of these arrangements are designed to move money made in the uk out to subsidiaries in other countries where lower rates of tax apply, and as corporation tax is levied on profits, starbucks was able to avoid paying uk corporation tax through complex international payments within the company known as transfer pricing. Some mps declared it inadequate, activists saw it as admission of guilt.
While the tax avoidance practices starbucks used were common among multinational companies, starbucks had been very public in its commitment to being socially responsible and a good citizen of the communities in which it operated. Starbucks corporation a tax avoidance controversies in the united kingdom starbucks coffee menu famously baffles some people. Starbucks suffers reputation slump over tax avoidance. Tax havens are jurisdictions which facilitate reduced taxes. Will starbucks set a precedence of obeying the spirit of corporate tax laws permanently and in all markets. It was accused of using artificial corporate structures to shift profits. Stung, starbucks plans to change its arrangements and pay uk.
On october there were allegations that starbucks were not paying tax in the uk. This paper examines the case of starbucks uk branch, which became subject to massive public criticism over alleged tax avoidance. All form types annual filings quarterly filings current reports proxy filings registration statements section 16 filings other. Concerns over the scale of tax avoidance rekindled interest in the idea, though. The importance of taxes and the effects of tax evasion and tax avoidance. Starbucks suffers reputation slump over tax avoidance oct 19, 2012 consumer goodwill drains away over coffee chains failure to pay tax as more politicians call for boycott. Amazon and starbucks take reputation hit from tax avoidance publicity both companies have regularly hit the headlines in recent years for paying low levels of corporation tax. For example, is it tax avoidance for a us company to move some research and development activity to the uk to take advantage of the uks.
News agency reuters carried out a fourmonth investigation looking at how the company was able to tell investors that is was profitable, even though it was consistently reporting losses. Starbucks became the poster child for corporate tax avoidance in 2012 after details of its meagre tax contribution emerged. After submitting your information, you will receive an email. China sets priorities for its antitax avoidance initiatives. Jun 27, 2019 starbucks ukbased european business paid just. Apr 18, 2014 starbucks said on april 16 it was relocating its european headquarters from the netherlands to britain a year after the u.
Over the past three years, starbucks has reported no profit, and paid no income tax, on sales of 1. Starbucks to boost pay and benefits after us lowers. It goes on to examine the debate over corporate tax avoidance and the international efforts, led by the oecd, to tackle avoidance by multinationals through base erosion and profit shifting beps. Why avoidance, evasion and administration are central, not peripheral, concepts in public finance 1426 1. Starbucks will use some of the savings from the new u. This may include the identification of tax efficiencies, such as use of or application for local tax incentives, reliefs, or exemptions, where legally available and permissible. Oct 16, 2012 us coffee giant starbucks reportedly paid just. Tax avoidance, evasion, and administration joel slemrod the university of michigan shlomo yitzhaki the hebrew university of jerusalem contents abstract 1425 keywords 1425 1. Starbucks tells investors that its uk units are making money, but it reports losses to the british taxman. Ethics of tax avoidance by starbucks uk essay 277 words 2 pages. Starbucks admitted that there were taken by surprise by the level of hostility and emotions surrounding the tax issue. Orders 2 nations to recover taxes from starbucks and fiat.
Ethics of tax avoidance by starbucks uk essay 277 words 2 pages starbucks media coverage of starbucks not paying corporation tax in the united kingdom in the last four years has shocked and angered many members of the british public. Starbucks brand suffers over tax claims marketing week. This article approaches tax avoidance as a crime of globalization. Starbucks brewed a tax storm starbucks secret sauce for tax avoidance gives us an excellent example of how to create phony expenses out of nothing by mere transfers on paper between a parent company and a subsidiary.
Starbucks stands out because it has told investors one. October 17, 2012 statement by starbucks coffee uks managing director starbucks commitment to the uk 17 october 2012 posted by starbucks following a number of stories in the media over the last day about starbucks and the amount of tax we pay each year, i believe its important that we share the facts with you on this important issue. To receive notifications via email, enter your email address and select at least one subscription below. Oct 18, 2012 starbucks brand suffers over tax avoidance claims. A reuters investigation has claimed that starbucks has payed only. The selection was based on the entities participation in the tax avoidance scandals, and on the availability of information.
A brands buzz score typically recovers quite qui ckly following a. Oct 15, 2012 this apparent contradiction arises from tax avoidance, and sheds light on perfectly legal tactics used by multinationals the world over. Consumers were taking things to social media causing an even bigger chaos for the company. December 2012, starbucks decides to make an above and beyond payment of. Starbucks faced negative publicity due to its tax practices as. Corporate tax avoidance is a practice that involves different. However, the committee will not permit the retention of the independent. The us coffee giant, which has been accused of tax avoidance by the european. China sets priorities for its anti tax avoidance initiatives november 15, 2018 in brief chinas state administration of taxation sat recently emphasized that the general principles underlying its anti tax avoidance initiatives are seeking improvement while ensuring stability, with the priority being crossborder profitlevel monitoring. Amazon and starbucks take reputation hit from tax avoidance.
970 289 457 1126 726 887 192 102 996 103 518 1403 175 142 305 1321 943 635 838 643 162 1448 1087 568 1233 1482 964 1304 1306 1503 657 1500 280 1412 551 1328 423 153 898 638 1084 112 161 129 446